You are not obligated to complete the work, neither are you free to abandon it.
– Pirkei Avot 2:16
Throughout history, there have been individuals dedicated to lessening the anguish of others. These Tzaddikim, or righteous ones, whether through social advocacy, art, or charity, have given hope to all who have known their generosity. They give of themselves not for recognition, personal gain, or influence, but to ensure that as many people as possible can experience the beauty life has to offer.
Doing the right thing is worth it for its own sake. To be created in the image of divinity means committing ourselves to doing good because our actions have the potential to make a positive impact, even if we do not directly benefit from the result.
In Parashat Chukat, Moses learns that he will not reach the Promised Land. After the weary Israelites lament that they are without water in the desert, God tells Moses and Aaron to assemble the community in front of a rock that would give forth water. Instead of speaking to the rock as God had instructed him to do, Moses struck it twice. Though water still flowed for the people and their animals, Moses’s faltering trust was an affront to God enough to get him barred from Eretz Yisrael.
This seems like an unfair punishment. Moses had journeyed with these people and dedicated his life to guiding them. It was Moses who had to deal firsthand with the vexation and unrest of the people with their brash calls to be returned to the bonds of slavery. What would the people do to Moses and Aaron if the water didn’t flow?
Perhaps God’s actions were not punitive, but a recognition that Moses’ purpose in the lives of the Israelites was to be their guide on the path to self-actualization. One can give a people the ability to govern themselves, but one cannot force them to build a just society. Justice and balance must come from within the ranks of any blossoming culture.
Societal holiness arises from moments where choices are made with an emphasis on compassion and consideration of the full impact on other living beings.
Like Moses, Ludwig van Beethoven, the iconic 18th-century German composer, faced his own profound challenges. Known as a prodigy from early in his life, Beethoven’s brilliance as a pianist, improviser, and composer spread rapidly throughout Europe. Tragically, around the age of 28, he began to lose his hearing. Beethoven withdrew from social gatherings and ceased performing, petrified that people would realize he could no longer hear the music.
The misery Beethoven endured was immense. How could someone with such a profound gift have it seemingly ripped away in the most cruel manner? In 1802, Beethoven wrote a heart-wrenching letter to his brothers, revealing his hearing loss and his contemplation of ending his life. It was his will to create art and contribute to humanity that saved him.
“Perhaps I shall get better, perhaps not; I am ready. – Forced to become a philosopher already in my twenty-eighth year, – oh it is not easy, and for the artist much more difficult than for anyone else. – Divine One, thou seest my inmost soul thou knowest that therein dwells the love of mankind and the desire to do good.”
L. V. Beethoven
Heiligenstadt Testament October 6, 1802
Beethoven could have surrendered to despair. Instead, he continued to compose music, creating some of his most profound works, including the Ninth Symphony, composed when he was almost completely deaf. His perseverance in the face of such a personal loss mirrors the determination and tenacity of Moses. Both individuals faced significant obstacles that could have halted their pursuits. Yet, instead of succumbing to hopelessness, they channeled their struggles into their life’s work, leaving a legacy that transcends their personal limitations.
In our own lives, we may face overwhelming challenges. We may have dreams that appear just out of reach, but like Moses and Beethoven, we are called to push forward with faith and determination. Our legacy is not solely in the destination, but in the journey and the spirit with which we pursue our goals.
Let us draw inspiration from Moses’s leadership and Beethoven’s resilience. Let us remember that while we may not always see the fruits of our labor, our efforts and dedication have a lasting impact. Whether we are guiding a community, creating art, or simply striving to be better people, our resolve in the face of adversity can inspire and uplift those around us.
May this Shabbat bring you peace, reflection, and renewed strength. May we all find the courage to face our impediments with grace and perseverance, and may our efforts leave a lasting legacy of hope and inspiration.
Shabbat Shalom,
Cantor Jake Harris
Temple Beth El of Boca Raton
